Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
8" Cheese Pizza
Cheese Sticks
Kids Hot Dog W/ Fries
Kids Mini Corndogs W/ Fries
About
Castaway Craig's Pub & Grub
Welcome to Castaway Craig's Pub & Grub, a delightful culinary oasis nestled at 2114 Grandview Rd, Lake Milton, OH. This charming pub strikes the perfect balance between a cozy retreat and a lively dining experience, making it a wonderful choice for both family outings and evenings with friends.
The menu at Castaway Craig's is a food lover's dream, especially for pizza enthusiasts. With a variety of offerings, from the unique Pickle Pizza to the crowd-favorite BBQ Chicken Pizza, each pie is crafted with quality ingredients. The 16-inch Castaway's Brier Hill stands out with its combination of savory sausage, sweet and hot peppers, and rich red sauce, offering a taste of local flavor for just $21.49. The diverse selection of sizes—16”, 12”, and 8”—ensures that there's an option for everyone, whether you’re dining solo or sharing with friends.
Beyond the inviting food, the atmosphere at Castaway Craig's is consistently praised by patrons. Guests have raved about the serene ambiance complemented by stunning views from the patio, where you can soak in the beauty of the nearby lake while enjoying your meal. A recent visitor, Jeremiah McAdams, noted the “serene ambiance” and “excellent service,” highlighting the strong rapport between staff and diners. This warmth truly makes Castaway Craig’s feel like a home away from home.
Moreover, the outstanding service is a recurring theme in customer reviews. Many guests, including Derek Hamper, have expressed gratitude for the friendly and welcoming staff, creating a memorable experience that draws visitors back time and again. It’s no wonder newcomers to the area, like V W, have discovered this hidden gem and can't wait to return.
In addition to its pizzas, the menu features hearty options like the Philly Cheese Steak and the Chicken Bacon Ranch, both of which have received high praise for their flavor and generous portions. Whether you choose fries or chips as a side, you’re in for a tasty treat.
Castaway Craig's Pub & Grub isn't just about good food; it's about creating an experience that lingers long after the meal is over. If you're looking for a place to unwind or share a lively meal, be sure to visit this inviting spot. With fair prices, a welcoming atmosphere, and delicious food, your visit will undoubtedly be well worth it!
For reservations or inquiries, call +1 330-557-9005, and make your way to this culinary haven in Lake Milton.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Whether you’re looking to unwind or enjoy a lively night out, Castaway Craig’s strikes the right balance with its serene ambiance, excellent service, and fair prices. Definitely worth a visit! ”
“ Enjoyable. Food, service, atmosphere all very good.nice view from patio.a little pricey but felt it was worth it.live entertainment while we were there was ok. ”
“ Great little hideaway restaurant near the lake. The food was delicious and the staff was amazing. I recommend the philly cheese and the chicken bacon ranch, with either fries or chips. Both were great and I cannot wait to head that way again for more. ”
“ So glad a neighbor told us about Castaway Craig's! It's off the beaten path, so we never would've discovered it, but what a great find! The food is delicious (with many side options), our server couldn't have been nicer, and the water/park view from the covered patio is lovely. We'll definitely be back soon. ”
“ Had a wonderful Saturday night outing. New to area and saw positive reviews so wanted to give it a try. Great service from bartender Amanda as she welcomed my spouse and I to the community. We ordered a tots basket and fried pickles to ... ”
“ We were originally supposed to go to a different restaurant but it was closed due to a plumbing issue - We figured we’d try this place - and so glad we did! The Cuban burgers with house made chips and dip were outstanding, as was the service provided by Molly! ”
“ Had drinks while a live band played. Music and staff were great. Our carry out food was amazing. Huge burgers with fresh toppings! We'll be back ”
“ Places is a perfect spot! The Locals finally get something to enjoy with the views. Not right on the lake but still better than nothing. Food was tasty. Ima stick with the philly sub wow! Tasty tasty! Had a small band which is why the atmosphere was just perfect. ”